Biophysical Chemistry, 2005, Vol. 117, No. 3, pp 207-215.

Melting temperatures of nucleic acids: Discrepancies in analysis

Melting temperature, T_m, is an important property of nucleic acid duplexes. It is typically determined from spectroscopic or calorimetric melting experiments. More than one analytical method has been used to extract T_m values from experimental melting data. Unfortunately, different methods do not give the same results; the same melting data can be assigned different T_m values depending upon which method is used to process that data. Inconsistencies or systematic errors between T_ms reported in published data sets can be significant and add confusion to the field. Errors introduced from analysis can be greater than experimental errors, ranging from a fraction of degree to several degrees. Of the various methods, the most consistent and meaningful approach defines melting temperature as the temperature at the transition midpoint where half of the base pairs are melted and standard free energy is zero. Assuming a two-state melting behavior, we present here a set of general equations that can be used to reconcile these analytical T_m differences and convert results to the correct melting temperatures at the transition midpoint. Melting temperatures collected from published sources, which were analyzed using different methods, can now be corrected for these discrepancies and compared on equal footing. The similar corrections apply to T_m differences between calorimetric and spectroscopic melting curves. New algorithm for selection of linear sloping baselines, 2nd derivative method, is suggested, which can be used to automate melting curve analysis.

• Mishra S., Ghosh S., Mukhopadhyay R. (2013) Maximizing mismatch discrimination by surface-tethered locked nucleic acid probes via ionic tuning. Anal. Chem. 85, 1615-1623.
• Ozel A.B., Srivannavit O., Rouillard J.M., Gulari E. (2012) Target concentration dependence of DNA melting temperature on oligonucleotide microarrays. Biotechnology Progress 28, 556-566.
• Hull C., Szewcyk C., St. John P.M. (2012) Effects of locked nucleic acid substitutions on the stability of oligonucleotide hairpins. Nucleosides, Nucleotides & Nucleic Acids 31, 28-41.
• Lin L.G., Liu Q.C., Wang L.M., Liu A.L., Weng S.H., Lei Y., Chen W., Lin X.H., Chen Y.Z. (2011) Enzyme-amplified electrochemical biosensor for detection of PML-RAR alpha fusion gene based on hairpin LNA probe. Biosensors & Bioelectronics 28, 277-283.
• De Giacomo F., Peifer M., Rajic Z., Vasella A. (2011) Oligonucleotide analogues with integrated bases and backbone part 28 hydrazide- and amide-linked analogues. 2. Di-, tetra-, octa-, and decamers: synthesis and association. Helvetica Chimica Acta 94, 1153-1193.
• Peifer M., Vasella A. (2011) Autonomously pairing cysteinyl-linked nucleotide analogues with a unique architecture. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 133, 4264-4267.
• You Y., Tataurov A.V., Owczarzy R. (2011) Measuring thermodynamic details of DNA hybridization using fluorescence. Biopolymers 95, 472-486.
• Hughesman C.B., Turner R.F.B., Haynes C. (2011) Correcting for heat capacity and 5 '-TA type terminal nearest neighbors improves prediction of DNA melting temperatures using nearest-neighbor thermodynamic models. Biochemistry 50, 2642-2649.
• Gao M., Gawel K., Stokke B.T. (2011) Toehold of dsDNA exchange affects the hydrogel swelling kinetics of a polymer-dsDNA hybrid hydrogel. Soft Matter 7, 1741-1746.
• Hariharan M., Siegmund K., Lewis F.D. (2010) Structure and stability of alkane-linked DNA hairpin conjugates. J. Org. Chem. 75, 6236-6243.
• Huguet J.M., Bizarro C.V., Forns N., Smith S.B., Bustamante C., Ritort F. (2010) Single-molecule derivation of salt dependent base-pair free energies in DNA. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 107, 15431-15436.
• Hikida Y., Kimoto M., Yokoyama S., Hirao I. (2010) Site-specific fluorescent probing of RNA molecules by unnatural base-pair transcription for local structural conformation analysis. Nat. Prot. 5, 1312-1323.
• Nasef H., Beni V., Ozalp V.C., O'Sullivan C.K. (2010) Cystic fibrosis: a label-free detection approach based on thermally modulated electrochemical impedance spectroscopy. Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry 396, 2565-2574.
• Lin L.Q., Lin X.H., Chen J.H., Chen W., He M., Chen Y.Z. (2009) Electrochemical biosensor for detection of BCR/ABL fusion gene based on hairpin locked nucleic acids probe. Electrochemistry Communications 11, 1650-1653.
• Owczarzy R., Tataurov A.V., Wu Y., Manthey J.A., McQuisten K.A., Almabrazi H.G., Pedersen K.F., Lin Y., Garretson J., McEntaggart N.O., Sailor C.A., Dawson R.B., Peek A.S. (2008) IDT SciTools: a suite for analysis and design of nucleic acid oligomers. Nucleic Acids Res. 36, Suppl. S, W163-W169.
• Owczarzy R., Moreira B.G., You Y., Behlke M.A., Walder J.A. (2008) Predicting stability of DNA duplexes in solutions containing magnesium and monovalent cations. Biochemistry 47, 5336-5353.
• Vives M., Tauler R., Eritja R., Gargallo R. (2007) Spectroscopic study of the interaction of actinomycin D with oligonucleotides carrying the central base sequences -XGCY- and -XGGCCY- using multivariate methods. Anal. & Bioanal. Chem. 387, 311-320.
• van Zalinge H., Schiffrin D.J., Bates A.D., Starikov E.R., Wenzel W., Nichols R.J. (2006) Variable-temperature measurements of the single-molecule conductance of double-stranded DNA. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 45, 5499-5502.
• You Y., Moreira B.G., Behlke M.A., Owczarzy R. (2006) Design of LNA probes that improve mismatch discrimination. Nucleic Acids Res. 34, e60.